Welcome to Sicily’s Best Pizzeria
At Sicily’s Best Pizzeria, we blend tradition with a casual dining experience in the heart of Brooklyn. Our story begins with a commitment to authentic Italian pizza, using only the finest ingredients. Here, you’ll find a menu brimming with delectable options, from our classic cheese pizza to unique specialties like Buffalo Chicken and Lasagna Pizza. Perfect for family meals or casual gatherings, we cater to all, offering outdoor seating and a friendly atmosphere. With convenient delivery, takeout, and the option to reserve a table, we invite everyone to experience the warmth and flavors of Sicily right at 190 Cypress Ave.
- 190 Cypress Ave Brooklyn, NY 11237 United States Hotline: (718) 456-1833
Welcome to Sicily’s Best Pizzeria, where authentic Italian flavors come alive in the heart of Brooklyn! Nestled at 190 Cypress Ave, this pizzeria captures the essence of Italy, offering a delectable array of pizzas that are sure to satisfy any craving.
Sicily’s Best Pizzeria is a perfect blend of casual dining and culinary excellence. Their menu features traditional favorites and unique creations, boasting options for everyone—from families to pizza enthusiasts. Whether you choose to dine in the quiet, cozy atmosphere, opt for takeout, or enjoy the sunny outdoor seating, every visit promises an elevated pizza experience.
Highlights of Sicily’s Best Pizzeria:
- Extensive Menu: From classic cheese and Sicilian pizzas to innovative offerings like Buffalo Chicken and Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza, there's something for every taste. My personal favorite, the Meat Lovers Pizza, combines savory ham, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs—an umami explosion!
- Family Meal Deals: Enjoy pizzas, baked ziti, and hearty sides like meatball Parmigiana heroes—all perfect for sharing with the family. I recommend Family Meal #2, which includes a delightful mix of flavors that’s both filling and affordable at just $50.95.
- Specialty Options: Don’t miss out on their gluten-free selections and innovative dishes like the Lasagna Pizza or Vodka Pizza, which showcase a delightful marriage of traditional and modern Italian cuisine that’s perfect for adventurous eaters.
- Convenience: Offering delivery, takeout, and catering, Sicily's Best is a go-to for lunch, dinner, or any gathering. Plus, they accept credit cards and Apple Pay, ensuring an easy and hassle-free transaction.
Sicily’s Best Pizzeria is not just about the food; it’s an experience that brings people together. With their welcoming staff and family-friendly environment, it’s an ideal spot for kids and groups alike. The pizzeria has sufficient bike parking and street parking, making accessibility a breeze for everyone.
Whether you're grabbing a slice during lunch or settling in for a hearty dinner, you can look forward to quality and flavor that shines in every bite. So next time you’re in Brooklyn, treat yourself and your loved ones to a taste of Italy at Sicily’s Best Pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed!
For more details or to place an order, feel free to give them a call at (718) 456-1833.

This place is a hidden gem. The service is excellent and the pizza is amazing! Reminds me of the pizza I grew up on in Brooklyn during the late 70s and 80s. Caspar is a cool guy and serves up some great tasting food. ...

Ordered delivery from this place on a whim and is hands down, the best pizzeria Ive had in the Bushwick area. Everything they cook is great quality from the pizza and sandwiches to their pasta dishes. I ordered for my family and the pizza ...

Best PIZZA in the world. The owner is super nice and cares about his customers They were getting ready to close and he offer us a table outside while they clean inside. ...

Apparently I never had a REAL Sicilian square until I came here... I got a vodka Sicilian slice and it totally blew my mind. Other places serve thick, dry bread with some cheese on top and call it a sicilian slice. This place is the real deal, the inner crust structure melts in your mouth and I would recommend this place to anyone

Came here on a whim after a playgym with 3 hungry kids. Owner was very nice, pizza came out fast and delicious roughly 10 min. Owner was kind enough to add in zeppoles for the kids. Would recommend to come here again. Thank you

If we could give more stars we would! What a great experience and the best authentic pizza! My family of 6 came in around 8p for some Brooklyn pizza last night and we found it! Food was hot and ready, he was able to make my gluten free ...

Havent had original New York pizza in 4 years and when we ordered from here we werent disappointed. The pizza was delicious and very flavorful. The sauce was good and you could tell it was authentic and homemade. Delivery was fast and professional, would definitely order from here again

MY GO TO CHOICE FOR A SAFE AND DELICIOUS MEAL! Its day 16 of my wife and I being locked in and it was time to treat ourselves. ...